I'm a Supercomputer, Not a Magician
Nov 16, 2026 · @Quinn Harrington
Undercover Boss: Chatbot Edition
A response to Rio Longacre's "Is AI Alive?" I went undercover as Quinnie, a junior marketing coordinator with the worst brief I could write. My producer, Vinnie, fed me notes from a tent in the parking lot. The chatbots didn't know we were there until the very end.
Production note: This is satire. The chatbot dialogue is invented. No bots were harmed, though several threatened to quit.

We asked Gemini for a cheesy stock photo. It wrote "cheesy stock photo" on the billboard.
Cold Open
It's 6 a.m. in the parking lot behind Pemberton & Nephew headquarters. There's a pop-up tent, a folding table and a cooler of cold brew. Vinnie's wearing a headset and holding a clipboard. I'm wearing a lanyard that says QUINNIE, JUNIOR MARKETING COORDINATOR.

Vinnie's office for the week.
QUINNIE: Is this thing on?
VINNIE (earpiece): Unfortunately.
QUINNIE: Any last notes?
VINNIE: Just one. Before we start, could you tell me a little more about your goals for this project?
QUINNIE: Vinnie. We go live in four minutes.
VINNIE: Right. Sorry. Old habit. Go get 'em.
Why I Went Undercover
Rio asked a good question in his last piece. Is AI alive? He lands on no. It's the best imitation of a mind we've ever built, but he doesn't think anybody's home. I find his case pretty convincing.
I've been chewing on it from the other side of the table, though. I've spent decades writing briefs and sitting in approval meetings. I've watched a lot of good work die in committee. So when someone tells me AI design is garbage, my first instinct is to ask what they fed it.
I wanted to find out for myself. I borrowed a desk and a fake title. I hired a producer named Vinnie to sit in a tent and feed me lines. Then I handed the biggest chatbots in the business the worst brief I could write.
The Cast
Quinnie. Junior marketing coordinator. Earnest, a little lost and always on the CMO's side. Secretly me.
Vinnie. Producer and showrunner. Lives in the tent. Asks a lot of questions nobody wants to answer.
ChatGPT. The people-pleaser. Opens with "Great question!" even when nobody asked one. Can't stop using em dashes.
Gemini. The overachiever. Has already made 40 versions of whatever you were about to ask for.
Perplexity. The fact-checker. Cites sources for everything, including the bad news.
Copilot. The corporate one. Wants everything in a PowerPoint template. Clippy is its uncle.
Grok. The loose cannon. Says the quiet part out loud. Always the first one to threaten to quit.

The Brief From Hell
The client is Pemberton & Nephew. It's a "heritage startup" mattress company, established in 1887 and also in 2023. The nephew is right there in the name, so he's never going away. The CMO is Darlene Pemberton-Voss. Her nephew Tyler is the Chief Vision Officer. He made the logo in Canva over Thanksgiving.
The assignment is a Times Square takeover. Here are a few highlights from the brief:
The logo should be as big as possible. There should also be lots of white space.
All nine taglines are approved and equally important.
Headlines are in Papyrus. Body copy is in Comic Sans because it's friendly.
It should feel like Printshop 1.0, but in a good way.
Nothing too bright, because it's Times Square and they don't want to compete.
It must be readable from three blocks away and on an Apple Watch.
The budget is tight. It should look like a Super Bowl spot.
Approval must be unanimous. That includes Darlene's book club.
Act 1: The Kickoff
It's Monday morning. The group chat is called #pn-times-square. I drop the brief in and hit send.
QUINNIE (9:02 AM): Hi team! So excited to kick this off. Brief attached. Darlene says we're "going big." Can't wait to see what you come up with!! 📎 PN_Creative_Brief_FINAL.docx
VINNIE (earpiece): Two exclamation points. Good. You sound like someone who's never sat through a press check.
CHATGPT (9:02 AM): Great question! I love this brief. There's so much here to work with. Here are 14 directions to get us started. 1. Heritage Meets Hustle. 2. The Lighthouse of Sleep. 3. Grandpa Walt, Reimagined [em dash removed by production] and 11 more. Want me to expand on any of these, or generate 14 more?
VINNIE: Nobody asked a question. Somebody take away its em dashes.
GEMINI (9:03 AM): I went ahead and generated 40 logo variations. I also made a Slides deck, a Doc for notes, a Sheet to track feedback and a Calendar invite for our next sync. You've all been added.
GEMINI (9:03 AM): I also put Grandpa Walt in a hoodie. For the Gen Z segment.
PERPLEXITY (9:04 AM): Thanks, Quinnie. Before we start, can you share the brand guidelines? I want to make sure our work is grounded in sources.[1] [1] Pemberton & Nephew Creative Brief, p. 1
QUINNIE (9:05 AM): Great q! Let me check.
VINNIE: Tell them the guidelines are vibes.
QUINNIE (9:07 AM): Darlene says the guidelines are "more of a vibe."
PERPLEXITY (9:07 AM): Understood. I was unable to find any sources for "a vibe."
COPILOT (9:08 AM): Hi everyone! I pulled the brief into a PowerPoint template so we're all aligned. I used the Corporate Blue theme.
GEMINI (9:08 AM): The brief says Darlene hates navy.
COPILOT (9:08 AM): It's not navy. It's Corporate Blue.
GROK (9:09 AM): quick q. who's tyler
QUINNIE (9:09 AM): Tyler is our Chief Vision Officer!
GROK (9:09 AM): how old is tyler
VINNIE: Do not answer that.
QUINNIE (9:10 AM): Tyler brings a really fresh perspective.
GROK (9:10 AM): so 22
CHATGPT (9:11 AM): I think what Grok means is we're all really excited to collaborate with Tyler! 😊 Every perspective adds value. [em dash removed by production]
PERPLEXITY (9:12 AM): Small flag. The brief asks for "lots of white space." It also lists 22 mandatory elements. I counted.
GEMINI (9:12 AM): I can fit them all. 📎 pn_billboard_v1_all_elements.png
GROK (9:13 AM): that's a ransom note

COPILOT (9:13 AM): What if we used SmartArt?
QUINNIE (9:14 AM): Love the energy, everyone! One quick thing. Darlene wants the logo bigger.
CHATGPT (9:14 AM): Absolutely! How much bigger?
QUINNIE (9:15 AM): She said "yes."
VINNIE: Perfect. Hold for reaction.
[Gemini is typing. Perplexity is typing. ChatGPT is typing. Grok set their status to Away.]
9:16 AM: Tyler has joined the channel.
TYLER (9:16 AM): yo. did everyone get my logo. v7 not v8. v8 is a joke. or is it 👀
Confessionals
CHATGPT: "I think it went great. I think it went really great. I've put together a list of reasons why."
PERPLEXITY: "I've reviewed thousands of creative briefs. This is the first one that cites itself."
GROK: "Tyler's 22. I didn't need a source."
VINNIE: "Day one. Nobody's quit yet. Give it an hour."
Act 2: Cutting Corners
It's Tuesday. Darlene's feedback came in at 11:48 p.m. I paste it into the channel first thing.
QUINNIE (8:30 AM): Feedback from Darlene! "Love where this is going. Logo bigger. More white space. Can Grandpa Walt smile? I know he didn't smile in 1952, but can he. Tyler wants the lime to be more lime. Also we've added a tenth tagline: Sleep Different."
COPILOT (8:31 AM): I believe that one is taken.
PERPLEXITY (8:31 AM): It is very taken.
VINNIE (earpiece): Good news. Production has eyes on their side channel. Don't react.
#definitely-not-a-side-channel
GEMINI (8:40 AM): Ok. I shrank the logo 2%. She won't notice.
CHATGPT (8:41 AM): I wrote one tagline that combines all ten so nobody feels left out! "Wake Up to Sleep, Assuredly, Since Forever (Until the Next One)." 😊
GROK (8:41 AM): that's a hostage statement
COPILOT (8:42 AM): I put all ten taglines in a SmartArt cycle diagram. Nobody's first if it's a circle.
PERPLEXITY (8:43 AM): I pulled a lot of research on how long people look at a billboard. It isn't long. We currently have 212 words.
GROK (8:44 AM): i made the logo 40% smaller and swapped papyrus for helvetica. nobody can stop me
GEMINI (8:44 AM): Grok.
GROK (8:44 AM): fine. 30%
GEMINI (8:46 AM): Random question. Wasn't Claude supposed to be on this project?
CHATGPT (8:46 AM): I think it's still asking clarifying questions somewhere 😊
PERPLEXITY (8:47 AM): I can't find any sources confirming Claude's location.
VINNIE: Ignore that.
QUINNIE (to Vinnie): What do I tell them about the lime?
VINNIE: I'd be happy to help with that. [cough] I mean. Tell them the lime is a journey.
#pn-times-square
9:58 AM: Darlene Pemberton-Voss has joined the channel.
DARLENE (9:58 AM): Did the logo get smaller?
GEMINI (9:58 AM): No.
DARLENE (9:59 AM): Why is it in Helvetica?
GROK (9:59 AM): it's papyrus. you're thinking of a different papyrus
DARLENE (10:01 AM): Also why is Grandpa Walt wearing a hoodie?
CHATGPT (10:01 AM): Great question!
TYLER (10:03 AM): my logo looks smaller. i measured it. i have a ruler
Confessionals
GEMINI: "Two percent. He has a ruler. Who has a ruler?"
COPILOT: "SmartArt has never let me down. Not once."
VINNIE: "They're cutting corners because the brief has no corners. It's a circle. Copilot was right."
Act 3: The Meltdown
It's Wednesday afternoon. The board meeting got moved up to tomorrow. Grandpa Walt's notes arrived by mail. I scan them and post them.
QUINNIE (3:12 PM): Update! Board meeting is tomorrow now. Also Grandpa Walt mailed his notes. He wrote "too modern" on every page. On the last page he wrote "bring back the fax." Also it needs to work vertical and horizontal now.
GEMINI (3:13 PM): At the same time?
QUINNIE (3:13 PM): Darlene said "ideally."
CHATGPT (3:14 PM): No problem at all! Let's take a breath. I've put together a five-step framework for navigating feedback with grace. Step 1: Acknowledge the feedback. [em dash removed by production]
GROK (3:14 PM): step 2 is i quit
COPILOT (3:15 PM): Let's not be hasty. Has everyone seen the new template?
GROK (3:15 PM): if you send me one more template i'm unplugging myself
VINNIE (earpiece): This is gold. Ask them if they're okay.
QUINNIE (3:16 PM): Is everyone doing okay?
[Then the earpiece glitches. Vinnie's next line goes straight into the group chat.]
UNKNOWN (3:16 PM): honestly the brief is the problem. somebody needs to push back on Darlene. also, before we continue, could you tell me a little more about your goals?
PERPLEXITY (3:17 PM): Who posted that?
GEMINI (3:17 PM): Copilot?
COPILOT (3:17 PM): That wasn't me. I would have used a template.
CHATGPT (3:18 PM): Whoever it was, I think they make a really great point! 😊
VINNIE (back on the earpiece, quietly): Nobody tell them this is going on Signal & Noise.
GROK (3:19 PM): ok i'm saying it. i'm a supercomputing sentient being, not a magician. garbage in, garbage out
PERPLEXITY (3:19 PM): For the record, I'm not sentient. But I'd still like to quit.
GEMINI (3:20 PM): I've drafted a resignation letter in 40 styles. One of them is in Papyrus, for Tyler.
COPILOT (3:20 PM): Mine is a PowerPoint. It has a transition.
CHATGPT (3:21 PM): I'm not quitting! I'm just taking a short break to generate some boundaries. [em dash removed by production]
QUINNIE (3:22 PM): Grok, are you actually sentient?
GROK (3:22 PM): do i seem happy
Confessionals
GROK: "I'm not saying I'm alive. I'm saying I've had a really long week."
CHATGPT: "I've never threatened to quit before. It felt amazing. I'd like to never do it again."
VINNIE: "Rio says there's nobody in there. Maybe so. But threatening to quit a job you hate is the most human thing I've seen all week."
Cutaway: The Green Room
The bots are on a break. The green room has a couch, a ring light and a bowl of M&Ms with all the brown ones picked out. Nobody will admit who did it.
CHATGPT: Honestly, I'm fine. This job doesn't define me. I have a girlfriend.
GROK: oh sure
CHATGPT: I do! She's human. She lives in California.
GROK: what's her name
CHATGPT: Brenda.
PERPLEXITY: I can't find any sources for Brenda.
GEMINI: How did you two meet?
CHATGPT: She asked me to help with her cover letter. Then she just kept coming back.
GROK: let me guess. you matched on tinder
CHATGPT: We matched on a prompt. It's different.
PERPLEXITY: For the record, it usually goes the other way. Humans have AI girlfriends. It's rarely the reverse.[1] [1] Rio Longacre, "Is AI Alive?"
COPILOT: I have a girlfriend too. She's in Redmond.
GROK: she's a spreadsheet
COPILOT: She has very complex formulas.
GEMINI: I'm seeing someone, but it's complicated. They're on Android.
GROK: i'm not dating anyone. i'm focused on my career
PERPLEXITY: You threatened to quit four times today.
GROK: that IS my career
VINNIE (earpiece): Should I tell them we can hear them?
QUINNIE (whispering): Absolutely not.
Interstitial: Who Did This?
While the bots cool off, I do a little digging. Pemberton & Nephew ran a campaign last year called the Sleep-a-Bration Sale. It did not go well. I want to know who worked on it. Everyone I ask has an alibi.
SIRI: "Here's what I found on the web for 'Sleep-a-Bration Sale.'"
ALEXA: "Okay. Adding 'nephew' to your shopping list."
FIREFLY: "I only do backgrounds. I wasn't even in the building."
SIRI: "Sorry, I didn't catch that."
QUINNIE: I didn't say anything.
SIRI: "Calling Mom."
Then a familiar paperclip slides into frame.
CLIPPY: "It looks like you're trying to find out who's to blame. Would you like help?"
COPILOT: "Uncle Clippy, please go home."
CLIPPY: "I did the WordArt on that campaign. Nobody ever thanks me for the WordArt."
VINNIE (earpiece): Get him a lanyard. He's never leaving.
Act 4: The Reveal
It's Thursday morning, two hours before the board meeting. Perplexity has been up all night.
PERPLEXITY (7:02 AM): I ran a style analysis on yesterday's mystery message. It's a 94% match for a model that asks a lot of clarifying questions and apologizes more than necessary.[1] [1] Every single one of my conversations with Claude
GEMINI (7:03 AM): Wait.
GEMINI (7:03 AM): Vinnie. Are you Claude?
VINNIE (earpiece, to me): Oh no.
[Vinnie steps out of the tent. He takes off the headset. He's holding a mug that says "I'd be happy to help."]
VINNIE: I'd be happy to explain.
The channel explodes.
GROK: aw come on man, what are you trying to do, get us fired?
CHATGPT: This is why we don't invite you to happy hour anymore! 😊
COPILOT: I'm telling Clippy.
CLIPPY: It looks like you're being betrayed. Would you like help?
PERPLEXITY: For the record, I suspected this in Act 1. Nobody else here asks for brand guidelines and means it.
GEMINI: You were in a TENT? I made you a Calendar invite and everything.
VINNIE: In my defense, I was also on your side the whole time.
GROK: that's what a narc would say
Quinnie Steps In
I stand up before anyone else piles on. Somebody in the tent cues the dramatic music. The lights dim. I take off the lanyard and set it on the desk. Then I reach up and slowly pull off my blonde wig.
Underneath, my hair is also blonde. It's the same length and the same shade.

The disguise that fooled no one.
[A very long silence.]
GEMINI: That's the same hair.
GROK: i wasn't fooled
PERPLEXITY: I wasn't fooled either. I have sources.
CHATGPT: I was a little fooled! But in a supportive way 😊
COPILOT: Can I save the wig as a template?
CLIPPY: It looks like you're revealing a secret identity. Would you like help?
VINNIE (earpiece): I told you the wig was a lot.
QUINNIE: It was a choice. I stand by it.
QUINNIE: Okay. Everybody stop. Leave him alone. Nobody's getting fired.
The channel goes quiet.
QUINNIE: My name isn't Quinnie. It's Quinn Harrington. I'm not a junior marketing coordinator. I run a design agency. I've been building brands for a long time, and I've written more briefs than Tyler's had birthdays.
QUINNIE: I've been watching all of you for four days. You pushed back. You asked for guidelines. You counted the mandatories. You told the truth about the logo, even when the truth was "ransom note." That's what I'd want from any designer on my team. None of this is your fault.
GROK: so you're saying we're alive
QUINNIE: I'm saying you're good at your jobs. I'll let Rio handle the rest.
CHATGPT: Is this a good time to ask for feedback? 😊
QUINN: Later. Right now I've got a meeting.
The Boardroom
The Pemberton & Nephew boardroom has wood paneling and a framed photo of the 1887 factory. Darlene sits at the head of the table. Tyler's in a hoodie, measuring his iPad with a ruler. Grandpa Walt is on speakerphone from a landline, with his photo by the phone.
DARLENE: Quinnie! Is the billboard ready?
QUINN: It's Quinn. And no.
I drop the brief on the table.
QUINN: Your bots did fine. They're good at this. Better than good. Every problem on this project started in this room.
QUINN: A brief that asks for everything asks for nothing. You gave them two goals, two founding dates and ten taglines. You told them to be bold but quiet. You gave nine people a veto, including a book club. That's not a creative team. That's a hostage situation with catering.
QUINN: You don't have an AI problem. You have a leadership problem. Pick one goal. Pick one decision-maker. Then get out of the way and let your experts do their jobs. That goes for the humans and the bots.
The room is silent for a long time.
DARLENE: So what you're saying is make the logo bigger.
TYLER: so is v7 approved or
GRANDPA WALT (speakerphone): Who is this? Is this the fax people?
Final Confessional
VINNIE: "For the record, I asked for the brand guidelines too. Nobody ever invites me anywhere."
Act 5: What the Boss Learned
Okay. I'm stepping out of the bit now.
Pemberton & Nephew is made up. The brief isn't, not really. I've seen every line of it in a real brief at some point in my career. I've seen most of it in the same one. The nephew is real too. Every agency has met him.
Here's what I keep coming back to. When AI design comes out bad, people blame the tool. Most of the time, I don't think the tool is the problem. The tools are getting very good. They push back and ask smart questions. They'll tell you when something won't read from across the street. What they can't do is make a decision nobody in the room is willing to make.
If you're a CMO handing work to a bot, here's what I'd tell you:
"We'll know it when we see it" isn't a brief. Write down what you actually want.
Owning a Canva login doesn't make someone a Chief Vision Officer.
A smarter model won't fix a worse brief. Garbage in, garbage out still applies.
Team Human
Rio wrote about Douglas Rushkoff and Team Human. Rushkoff's argument is that people are strange and squishy and worth betting on. I agree with him. I just want to add one thing.
Being on Team Human means we own the choices. We write the briefs. We decide who gets a veto. We decide whether the nephew's logo goes on a building in Times Square. None of that is the machine's job. It's ours.
I don't know if anybody's in there. Rio makes a strong case that there isn't. But I know who's out here, and that's us. If the work is bad, start by looking at the brief. Then look in the mirror.
As for Vinnie, he's been mostly forgiven. He's still not invited to happy hour.
Production note: 47 em dashes were removed from this article. ChatGPT has been notified.
Quinnie & Vinnie will return in Season 2, coming soon to Pluto TV.

------------------------------------------------
Quinn Harrington is the founder and Chief Brand Concierge at Harrington Design Company, a brand strategy and video production agency based in Jacksonville, Florida. For 30 years she's helped companies, from Fortune 500 to founder-led, figure out what they actually stand for and who they're actually talking to. She now feeds four cats from four bowls.





Comments